3 Comments
User's avatar
Luke Lea's avatar

Off topic, but how in the world did the first ribosomes evolve?

Jonathan Ouyang's avatar

there’s many theories — im partial to the one where, like the spliceosome, the proto-ribosome was a parasite. in this view early ribosomes were rna catalysts that, due to amino acid ubiquity, synthesized small peptides which aided it in survival and proliferation

Luke Lea's avatar

Thanks for replying!. Not that I truly understand what you just wrote. Irreducible complexity is a much bigger hurdle for the origin of life than the evolution of the eye wouldn't you agree? This is not to say it might not eventually be solved. I'm completely agnostic.

OTH, with String Theory we are informed that there are virtually an unlimited number of possible universes (greater than 10 to the power of 500) and that we just happen to live in one that allows the evolution of life to occur: with just the right set of elements in the periodic table, the right set of elementary particles and the forces between them at just the right strengths, a cosmological constant tuned just right (down to a very large number of significant digits) etc. The Standard Model has more than twenty free parameters that have to be put in by hand. Even Witten now throws up his hands.

On the positive side, I once did a rough calculation of how long it would take the average protein to synthesize using Fisher's estimates of the probabilities and it came out about right, assuming that with crossing over every gene evolves independently and in parallel. But that was before I started thinking about the evolution of gene expression, so now I don't know.

I once read the definition of a miracle as an exceedingly unlikely event of enormous human consequence. By that standard the universe is a miracle and quite posssibly the appearance of life as well. But, then, so was the appearance of Lincoln at just the right time, to say nothing of the collection of geniuses who came together to write and approve the Declaration of Independence and the US Constitution (including the Bill of Rights).

And, damn, where does something so fundamental as sentience and consciousness come from? Is it truly an emergent property of matter as opposed to being something inherect in the laws of nature themselves? Why does pain hurt and not simply repel?

Don't get me wrong. I'm not declaring for ID but neither do I think we can rule it out on scientific grounds. (Of course science rules it out by assumption a la Laplace.) It certainly should not be ruled out in our public schools or other state institutions but should instead be left alone. Which is not to deny the historical importance, and indeed the truth, of Judeo-Christianity, on empirical grounds. See here for instance if you read to the end: https://shorturl.at/bxlTr

I'm just a layman, a complete amateur, and claim nothing more. And I truly love science!